Shop Now $31 Kimiko's brow pencils have been a go-to of Black's for years. "The tip is a superfine, extremely precise point that makes it easy to create the illusion of realistic brow hairs," Best natural-looking eyebrow pencils: At a glance. Best eyebrow pencil for thin brows: Clinique Quickliner For Brows. Best eyebrow pencil for fuller brows: Barry M Brow Wand. Best eyebrow pencil From easy-to-use eyebrow pencils you can get at the drugstore to sophisticated brow pencils that give the illusion of microblading, our editors' favorites. Marie Claire × A good eyebrow pencil has the power to fill in and define sparse brows. To help find the best ones, we tried 38 top-rated options to discover the seven best eyebrow pencils. To help you sift through your options, we tried nearly 40 pencils in The Lab, then narrowed it down to those with the best tips, pigments, and staying power. These are the best brow pencils tested by Byrdie. The best eyebrow pencils for 2023 are: Best overall - BBB ultra thin brow definer 2.0: £19, Bbb-london.com. Best for natural brows - MAC eyebrow styler: £18.50, Maccosmetics.com. Best value tyJn.